behindpyramids ([info]behindpyramids) wrote,
@ 2008-05-10 01:42:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Current mood: paranoid

Temporary Security
Some days I worry about privacy. The interiority of my life—more than most of my friends, more than most of my relatives, perhaps more than I know about me— is online. There is a blithe blindness in writing publicly. I am not considering the friends of the friends who potentially have access to this, the person who found this on a computer’s browsing history I forgot to delete, or the people who will track me down years from now.

Yet, when I stop to censor myself, to narrow the broad range of topics, to eliminate this or that person from today’s rant because my words may get back to them, it feels as if fetters are locking themselves over my wrist. I don’t want to be prudent; I want to write as if this were a cheap diary with a lock that I hid in my underwear drawer. It is not satisfying otherwise.

Instead I tell myself that there are so many people online, so many things to do, and so little time. I don’t imagine anyone could be particularly interested in stalking me.

So wrote the girl who posted her address online, the suicidal boy who transferred sophomore year, or the high school freshman who described her fantasies about her crush in explicit detail. No one seemed to care in real life, and it seemed impossible that anyone would bother to read them online, so they described their lives in morbid detail.

I read their blogs, waded through pages of bad writing and spelling mistakes written by people I barely knew, because I found it fascinating to watch their masks crumble to pieces on their faces.

Columnists like Anna Quindlen have written articles mourning the disappearance of privacy for the internet generation. I’m not sure how I feel. In high school I shared my blog with school mates. Most of the people I knew well did not read it. Somehow though, I got to know a small circle of people whom I never would have imagined befriending: upperclassmen I was too shy to talk to, underclassmen I had no classes with, people I liked but somehow never saw. I’m still in touch with several of them now. I love hearing from them, I read their updates, and I think about them from time to time. I hope they are doing well.

Sharing blogs with my college friends has allowed us to describe the details of our lives, capture the intensity of our emotions in the moment, or just rant about or day, at our own convenience. The key to relationships is time: time to sit down and talk over lunch, time to check in with each other, and that doesn’t happen often. Being able to read what’s going on in each other’s lives prevents us from falling out of touch when we don’t see each other.

Yet, I am worried about the day I slip up- perhaps I already have- and an employer reads something bad and fires me, or a friend of a friend of a friend that I wrote about somehow gets this address and reads something cruel I wrote about them, years and years ago.

What I really worry about though, is vulnerability. In my last blog a couple people left vitriolic anonymous notes that stung for months afterwards. I worry what I post is too honest, too full of emotion, and I have just sauntered naked across the screen for everyone and their pet elephant. Then one day, when I am comfortably ensconced in my post as mayor of New York, all of this will come out and my career will crash. Or that you, right now, are judging me. Are you the boy who sits next to me in class? Do you laugh when I write about despair because I know nothing about despair?

We are taught not to cry in public when we are small. It is loud, it embarrasses our parents, and it disturbs other people. Rather, we must put our best foot forward, learn to shake hands with a firm grip, and perfect our smile for the camera because the moment we are born we are entered into a grand competition for resources in the world: food, shelter, and the means to obtain more of each.

We are told to practice impression management because it will help us during interviews. We learn to present our best self, gloss over our mistakes and failures, and focus on moments when we have outshone everyone else around us. The result is a toxic cycle where everyone constantly feels outshone and constantly tries to outshine everyone else. People around me still talk about their SAT scores.
“Ooh man, I studied so hard and it paid off. I got a 750 on math.”
“Really? I took it cold and got a perfect score on math.”
“Oh, well, you know I didn’t study that much. Besides, they gave me a scholarship. Pretty awesome.”
“Sadly, I’m not eligible for a scholarship. My family makes too much money.”

Similarly, it becomes natural to snap something sarcastic at someone who hurts our feelings instead of saying: “You hurt my feelings,” because feelings make us vulnerable.

No wonder blogs are so compelling. It’s a relief to know how vulnerable everyone is behind the impervious iron smiles that go up every day. It’s a relief to know that other people are just like you: more vulnerable, fragile and beautiful than you could possibly imagine.

It’s also a relief because now you have blackmail material on them.

I am going friends only this summer for my internship.* Please leave a note if you've been lurking, and you'd like me to friend you.


*Mostly because I have a bad bad feeling that during my last internship my boss could have/maybe/probably did read this.



"They who would give up an essential liberty for temporary security, deserve neither liberty or security."
-Benjamin Franklin




(Post a new comment)


[info]cougarfang
2008-05-10 06:15 am UTC (link)
I leave my journal unlocked on principle - I hate it when someone interesting-looking comments somewhere or is linked by someone else and I follow their journal back only to find it's friends-locked. (Though I don't consider myself as posting particularly interesting things, but it's the thought that counts?) And anyway, I consider myself one of the Faceless Masses... safety in numbers and "anonymity" (though not really)... Some things I kind of have to lock (I think my parents occasionally read my LJ o_o;; No absolute proof, though.) but on the whole, I don't mind sharing my brain with other people.

It's kind of like... "people don't exist on the interwebs!" or "they're not real people!" kind of feeling. Our monkey brains aren't exactly adapted for teh Internets.

But yeah, there's the whole problem with bosses knowing about you and stuff... The More You Know.

Toxic cycle. Srsly. Especially in this world, where there are so many people shining so hard and you just kind of melt back into the Faceless Masses... Red Queen Theory.

There's also the opposite, in which people lie/exaggerate about doing badly for false humility, and no one believes them - like reverse psychology. Much of that rampant in my school. "Oh man, I did so bad on that last AP test, I totally like guessed on half the multiple choice..." "The essay section totally killed me, I'd be lucky if I got a 3..."

I'd probably have more to say if I weren't brain-dead >_>;;

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]behindpyramids
2008-05-13 02:32 pm UTC (link)
Agree. But then I start feeling violated when people I don't want to read my LJ, read it...and it occurs to me that this is my fault.

I really like the openness though, because I love making friends with random people who stumble upon this, and when you are friends only, its impossible.


False humility. Yes. I had a thought about that somewhere. It's like outshining each other in being nice...because the thing about false humility is how the person does does slip out. they don't create the impression that they are stupid, just very very modest.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]gottalovemn
2008-05-10 06:30 am UTC (link)
ewwww. i can't believe people at your school talk about SAT scores. x_x

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]pimmers
2008-05-10 09:28 am UTC (link)
Heh, I was thinking the same thing. Yay Swat?

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]behindpyramids
2008-05-10 04:33 pm UTC (link)
*gasp* Heavens. Next you'll be telling me people at Swat are actually discussing the current election...

In all seriousness how would you categorize the feel at Swat? I'm trying to sort out the personality of this college but I can't tell because I've never attended another college. Also it's hard to figure out what's because of the people I interact with (I have no interest in politics...therefore why would I discuss it?) vs. the actual personality of this place.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]behindpyramids
2008-05-10 04:37 pm UTC (link)
We're just that "cool." At first I thought it was just my sect of friends...but no...no....definitely not.

Oh btw...for our non-fic class someone wrote a piece about our state. They had visited and interviewed a guy who lives fifteen minutes away from me at home and then written up in the interview.
Here's a direct quote.

"He told me that the faculty at his high school tried to get him to remove or revise sections of the speech he gave as Valedictorian at his high school graduation, because the concepts and vocabulary “sounded too intellectual.” Out East, he said, everyone pushes you to achieve, to excel, to win; but in the Midwest, no one would expect you to want to go to Harvard."


Thoughts?
(I reacted rather, uh...strongly, especially given our high school experience.)

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]appleshoelace
2008-05-10 12:23 pm UTC (link)
I can definitely identify with this - as you know, because I have written about it myself before. It's so odd. My journal here is FO, and I wouldn't change that, because I write things that could identify me. But then, because it's FO, I don't try to make it interesting or entertaining, the way I would if it were public for anyone to read. Partly because that would seem pretentious - it would take away the feeling of being real. And partly because one gets comfortable with friends, and it somehow takes the edge off any motivation to try to write well. And there is the feeling that because it's hidden, it's a good place to ... take a dump, I guess! Get rid of all the crap that needs getting rid of! And so it then becomes quite a negative place. So yes, that is my experience of going FO.

But then, when I had a public diary on our previous site, although it was great fun and very freeing to bare my soul to the world and try to write in clever and experimental ways, I did start to feel very exposed and naked. Because anyone can come along and laugh at you in your nakedness, and trample all over it! I do have a public diary elsewhere at the moment, but it's full of silliness and nothing personal - it's like the opposite extreme of my diary here. I keep thinking I would really like to start a proper public blog, where I carefully consider what I write, and make it interesting, and indeed bare my soul to a degree, but in a way where it doesn't actually reveal anything that could identify me. But that seems like it would take some planning, and so I keep putting it off.

But I do think it is a bit foolish when people post their full name and address and phone number publicly! I think the internet culture does encourage some people to lose all sense of privacy. But I think writing about one's inmost feelings is a different matter. There is still a freeing anonymity about it. You are just one nameless person among thousands, writing emotions that are shared by everyone in some way or other.

(Reply to this)


[info]sartorias
2008-05-10 02:25 pm UTC (link)
I'm seeing disturbing evidence all over that the workplace and blogs is a big issue. it used to be blogging during company time but now it's like (generalizing here) there's some ferret in the company either paid to snoop, or is snooping in order to further their own interests, and tags likely entries for the boss. Brrrr.

Privacy is changing....the weird thing is, one can talk intimately, but it doesn't rebound in one's faces the same way as, say, standing up at a party or work meeting and saying the same things would. The consequences are not immediate and in personal physical space.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]cougarfang
2008-05-11 06:05 am UTC (link)
the weird thing is, one can talk intimately, but it doesn't rebound in one's faces the same way as, say, standing up at a party or work meeting and saying the same things would. The consequences are not immediate and in personal physical space.

I think in a way, the feeling is somewhat related to the oddity of what happens sometimes, when one is in a situation with two other friends and there's something you feel that you can tell them both individually in private, but not in this situation when they're both present... kind of, I don't mind you knowing, and I don't mind "you" knowing, but I mind that you and "you" know that both of you know... or something like that >_>;;

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]sartorias
2008-05-11 01:25 pm UTC (link)
Yes! That's it.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]socrateswarrior
2008-05-10 03:25 pm UTC (link)
I think that despite what we are all told - you hit the nail on the head when you mentioned being hushed as a child - many people feel the same way. I know I do, and my personal history has shown that people in general feel a whole lot more than they admit to.

This idea does explain why plays and performances have always been and will always be a popular socially emotional outlet. Actors in plays (and to a slightly lesser extent movies) show and feel the emotions that in some way are universal to the human species. They represent our inner selves; the inner self that you're referring to in this post. Your insecurity is natural, and you've already explained why. But by the same token, it is appealing. Most of us aren't yet completely conditioned socially. We still need to feel as if we're satisfying our own emotional need. So when we see someone living out the fulfillment or satisfaction of that need, by any medium, we're drawn to it.

P.S. Friend me pleez! haha

(Reply to this)


[info]tamasha420
2008-05-10 04:32 pm UTC (link)
wow- so true. I've often thought about it- and sometimes I feel like I'm censoring myself on here, because if for some reason I want to vent about a friend I have on here, I can't. or because people judge- when I just want to write things that are vitriolic, utterly ridiculous, creepy, or just immature, I worry that people will judge/complain. and then I write the entry, and then blush over it and make it private- but that somehow seems like cheating.
I guess there is no real safe haven, except for a cheap diary you stash in your underwear drawer. and then, too, there's the fear of judgment: someone may find it, or you may read it later and cringe over it, or... something.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]cougarfang
2008-05-11 06:06 am UTC (link)
That's what filters are for. XD;;;;;

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]behindpyramids
2008-05-11 03:48 pm UTC (link)
I prefer not to mess with filters just because I can see myself colossally messing up. Forgetting who is in what filter, or maybe adding someone because I want them to read one entry and then forgetting that that particular filter can see all these other backlisted entries...(because right now I can tell I'd be too lazy to create a separate filter for each entry.)
Also I feel a little squeamish assigning people to filters or different levels of trust. Sure I do that in my head, but at least then it's in my head, and people aren't looking through my lj-calander trying to figure out if something filtered them out.
Also things have this way of getting back to other people...and once it's online its the work of two seconds to copy something into an e-mail and send it. Sure I might trust the people in the filter, but if I go over the line or offend their nearest and dearest without being aware of it...
*brain shuts down*

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]karevlis
2008-05-12 06:02 am UTC (link)
not sure if we're still LJ friends, but i do still read when i get the time :)

you seem very calm in this entry. it's different.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]behindpyramids
2008-05-13 02:30 pm UTC (link)
that made me laugh.
one of my friends used to claim i'm ridiculously calm. i claimed in return that he has significant issues if he thought that. or a strange definition of calm.

how have you been doing?

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]geekgirl84
2008-05-12 05:17 pm UTC (link)
"It’s a relief to know that other people are just like you: more vulnerable, fragile and beautiful than you could possibly imagine."

Amen! I love this world of blogging and I'm glad that I "know" you. I'll be reading this summer :)

(Reply to this)


[info]esgalaith
2008-05-27 12:45 pm UTC (link)
Oog! I've only just seen this, did you friend me?? If not, tis okay, but I'll MISS you! I've been without internet access for faaar too long, but am now safely moved and have webbiness again. Huzzah!

I tend to alternate, (as I am amazingly paranoid,) between posting things that are Friends Only, and things that are randomly for public consumption.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]esgalaith
2008-05-27 12:48 pm UTC (link)
Ah, oki, yes, I am that silly. I failed to see the lock icon on this post, so my question is moot! 0.o Hahah. :)

(Reply to this) (Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login or password?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…